Hola, reader! Today I’d like to talk about a book I read
in my English class called The
Breadwinner by Deborah Ellis. It is about an eleven year old girl named
Parvana living in Kabul, Afghanistan under Taliban rule. It talks about the
struggles she faces before and after her father’s arrest (which is in the
beginning of the book). I found this book to be entertaining since it is in the
perspective of Parvana and also educational for the reader because they learn
more about the living conditions of Afghanistan in this period of time. But
enough about that, let’s get on to the main reason you’re here!
Towards the end of the book, Parvana goes into a
crumbled, ruined building to find shelter from the rain outside. Later on in
the chapter, she hears a girl crying nearby. Immediately, she rushes to her
side and tries to calm her. Then she openly tells the stranger at the time her
secret of dressing up as a boy. This confuses me because she doesn’t know who
the person really is, why she is there, and her views on the secret Parvana
told. Also, she is not supposed to tell that to anybody (except her family who
know already), let alone a stranger! Why would she do that? I guess she was trying
to make the girl feel better but she didn’t think that through apparently. This
was not a smart choice of Parvana’s in my opinion because a Taliban solider or
citizen could have been walking nearby coincidentally and heard the conversation
being held. Parvana wouldn’t even know
that happened considering it was pitch black outside during the conversation
(if the person didn’t approach her).